top of page

Debunking the Myth: Do Pets Really Need Supplements on a Balanced Diet?

Claws 'n Paws

Every pet owner wants the best for their furry companions. Many believe that if pets are fed a balanced diet, they do not need additional supplements. This myth is widespread and often causes confusion for owners who strive to keep their pets healthy. However, the idea that a balanced diet alone meets every pet's nutritional needs deserves closer inspection.


In this post, we’ll break down this myth and highlight why supplements can be vital for your pet's overall health and well-being as part of their balanced diet.


Relaxed, happy Golden Retriever
Relaxed, happy Golden Retriever

Understanding Pet Nutrition


To grasp the importance of supplements, we first need to understand what constitutes a balanced diet for pets. Dogs and cats are primarily carnivorous (with cats being obligate carnivores), though dogs have adapted to include more diverse food sources in their diets. A balanced diet typically comprises proteins, carbohydrates, fats, vitamins, and minerals.


Raw diets, commercial kibble, and homemade meals can all provide balanced nutrition if they meet the specific needs of your pet. Factors like age, breed, weight, activity level, and existing health issues play a significant role in determining what constitutes a balanced diet for each pet. For example, a dog's protein needs can vary significantly. An active Labrador may require about 20% more protein compared to a sedentary Dachshund.


The Limitations of a Balanced Diet


A balanced diet, while beneficial, may still fall short in certain areas:


  1. Bioavailability: Just because a food contains essential nutrients does not guarantee absorption. Some commercial pet foods might not provide nutrients in forms your pet can effectively use, leading to inefficiencies. For example, certain minerals in kibble may not be readily absorbed by your pet.


  2. Specific Needs: As pets age, their nutritional requirements change. For instance, studies show that senior pets often require up to 50% more glucosamine to maintain joint health compared to younger animals. Certain medical conditions, like allergies, might also necessitate specialized diets and supplements that standard food cannot fulfill.


  3. Food Quality Variability: The nutritional quality of pet food can differ greatly from brand to brand. For instance, a survey found that 30% of popular pet foods did not meet the nutritional standards established by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO). This inconsistency might leave your pet lacking essential nutrients.


  4. Dietary Restrictions: Pets with allergies or intolerances may struggle with certain foods, leading to nutrient deficiencies. For example, a dog truly allergic to chicken may miss out on essential amino acids typically found in poultry-based diets.


    Kibble and fresh food, side-by-side
    Kibble and fresh food, side-by-side

Why Supplements May Be Necessary


Given these limitations, supplements can help bridge nutritional gaps. Here are some scenarios where pet supplements can provide significant benefits:


  1. Joint Health: Many pets develop joint issues as they age. Glucosamine and chondroitin can help maintain and support healthy joints. Research shows that around 65% of senior dogs experience arthritis, making these supplements vital.


  2. Skin and Coat Quality: Omega-3 and Omega-6 fatty acids are essential for maintaining healthy skin and a shiny coat. Pets suffering from dry skin or allergies may benefit from adding these fats to their diet. Studies suggest that 70% of pets with skin allergies respond positively to Omega-3 supplementation.


  3. Digestive Health: Probiotics are often recommended to support gut health in pets. They can help balance intestinal bacteria, improving nutrient absorption. A recent study showed that 80% of pets with gastrointestinal issues benefited from probiotic supplements.


  4. Immune System Support: Certain vitamins and minerals play a role in strengthening the immune system. Antioxidants like vitamins C and E can help reduce cell damage from free radicals. Regular supplementation can lead to better overall health and increased disease resistance.


  5. Behavioural Support: Some supplements, such as those containing omega fatty acids and specific herbs, may assist in managing anxiety or hyperactivity. Owners have reported positive behavioural changes in 60% of dogs after introducing calming supplements.


Consulting Your Veterinarian


Before introducing any supplements into your pet's diet, it is crucial to consult your veterinarian for a health check, and then you should consider partnering with a pet nutritionist that is able to customize a diet plan for your pet. These professionals can offer personalized advice based on your pet’s health history, dietary needs, and lifestyle.


Not all supplements are created equal, and it's vital to choose those backed by research and safety standards.


Potential Risks of Over-Supplementation


While supplements offer benefits, it’s important to use them thoughtfully to avoid over-supplementation. Just like humans, pets can suffer from negative side effects if they consume excessive amounts of certain vitamins or minerals.


For instance, too much calcium can lead to skeletal problems in growing puppies, while an overload of Vitamin A can cause toxicity. Therefore, always follow your pet's care team's recommendations on dosage and frequency of supplements.


We always say that you cannot out-supplement a poor diet.


Final Thoughts


While a balanced diet is essential for your pet's health, it may not always provide everything they need. Many factors can impact their nutritional requirements, making supplements a useful addition.


Understanding how supplements work can empower pet owners to make informed choices for their companions. Always consult your veterinarian and pet nutritionist to tailor your pet's nutrition appropriately and consider supplements when necessary to support their optimal health.


It's time to challenge the belief that pets don’t require supplements if fed a balanced diet. Your pet's health deserves the best care possible, and incorporating the right supplements could be a significant part of their nutritional strategy.


If you want to invest in your pet's dietary health, click here for our diet package plans that are fully claimable from your pet insurance should you have holistic cover included.

 
 
 

Commentaires


Get a Free Pet Insurance quote here

Pets24 Approved Partner Badge

Cape Town, South Africa

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • TikTok

©2025 by Claws 'n Paws Pet Services

Monday to Thursday: 09:00 - 15:00

Friday: 09:00 - 14:30

Saturday & Sunday: Closed 

Public Holidays: Closed

bottom of page